Observing God’s Good Creation: The Fascinating Life History of Killdeer

Killdeer (Charadrius vociferous) birds are masters of deception. They lay eggs on the ground—right in plain sight—except that they are hard to see.  If their nest is approached, the killdeer parent will distract the intruder by running along the ground, sometimes calling loudly—hence the vociferous portion of the Latin name provided to them by Carl Linnaeus in 1758.  Once attention is gained, the killdeer may frequently crouch on the ground and put up one of its wings in an awkward pose as if it is broken.  This effective strategy draws the attention of a possible egg-eater away from the nest.

The first time I encountered a killdeer was in the Bighorn Basin in central Wyoming.  I was searching for fossils when I noticed a small bird nearby, running away from me and then crouching on the ground with its wing up and screeching loudly. I immediately turned and began walking toward it to see if it was hurt.  I had only taken a few steps when the bird suddenly ran forward another 10 feet and repeated the routine. I continued to follow. Suddenly it took flight, squawking all the way. I continued on with my fossil hunting. Thinking back, I now realize that I must have been very close to a killdeer nest sitting open on the desert ground but the bird had led me away.  It was a clever ruse and one that worked well to protect the killdeer eggs.

The following day I saw a killdeer in the same area, from afar, and took some pictures but did not approach it again.  Two years later I re-examined those photos for possible use in this article and to my great surprise some of the pictures show the killdeer standing by a nest with three eggs. I had even edited one of those photos in the past and never noticed the nest!

A killdeer stands by its nest containing three eggs near Greybull, Wyoming. At the time I took this photo I was not aware of the nest. Photo: Joel Duff

Not more than a week later on the same vacation, our family visited Monument Rocks in Kansas.  Again, we were looking for fossils when I spotted a bird making a lot of noise and acting strangely.  The same series of events occurred as did in Wyoming. I took a couple of pictures and started to walk toward it. I still did not know what kind of bird it was and I was unaware of the nest.  But my eight-year-old daughter called me back over to where I had been when I first noticed the bird and pointed out to me the eggs she had found lying nearby on the ground. Sure enough, there were four speckled eggs laying in a “nest” made of pieces of a shattered giant clam shell fossils.  

This killdeer successfully distracted me from its nest at Monument Rocks in Kansas. Fortunately my daughter has good eyes and was able to locate the nest. Photo: Joel Duff

A killdeer nest with four eggs. This nest is made among fragments of giant clam shells and other fossilized oyster shells. Photo: Joel Duff

This spring, nearly two years later, I found myself walking along train tracks in Canton, Ohio, near the Football Hall of Fame.  Suddenly I noticed a small bird running away at a right angle about twenty feet ahead. It made a shrill sound and then crouched and put its wing up.  This time I wasn’t fooled by the distraction. I was fully aware of what kind of bird it was and immediately recognized that it was attempting to change my direction.  I ignored the bird and slowly kept walking along the tracks. Twenty feet later I finally spotted what I was looking for: four killdeer eggs nestled on the gravel bed of the railroad tracks.

A killdeer nest with four eggs is in full view but it is difficult to see. It is the right of the railroad tie in the foreground. Photo: Joel Duff

Four specked eggs sit in a killdeer nest along a railroad track in a busy park in Canton OH. Photo: Joel Duff

I had learned about killdeer behavior from my previous experience in Kansas and I put that knowledge to use this time. Instead of being drawn away from the nest, I used the killdeer behavior to find the nest.

The killdeer life history makes for a remarkable story of how cleverly disguised eggs, delayed egg hatching and adult behaviors combine to allow a “shorebird” to live very successfully in a wide variety of environments including highly urban settings.

Let’s look a bit closer at what makes this species of bird, which is widespread across North America, so special.

Hiding in plain sight: minimal nests with maximum camouflage

Killdeer choose to nest directly on the open ground, preferably among small rocks. They will nest on gravel roads, on gravel rooftops of houses, and in open fields. They will avoid nesting near shrubs or other objects we think might provide some cover or shielding. It’s as if to say, I am going to nest where you would least expect me to, so you won’t be looking for me!  

Nests are just small scratches in the ground or a few pebbles or rocks moved to create a shallow depression to lay eggs.  Killdeer adults are difficult to see when they are sitting on their nests (see photos at the end of this article for an example). There are times when they don’t move from the nest when approached because their motion may be easier to spot than the birds themselves.  But its the eggs they lay that are especially well-suited for their environment.  The speckled eggs blend into their surroundings whether it be gravel, rocks or soils. Sometimes, the killdeer will bring a few items to the nest to further camouflage the eggs.  Most killdeer eggs are remarkably similar in appearance.  The are a light sandy color with brown to black splotches. However, some coloration pattern variation on killdeer eggs does occur.  For example, there were small, red-colored flecks on the eggs that I observed in Kansas and the fossil substrate upon which the birds had nested also contained some small red rocks.

A close up image showing the speckled pattern the killdeer eggs I found in Canton OH. Photo: Joel Duff

Devoted parents share nesting duties

Killdeer mates share nesting duties taking turns incubating the eggs.  When I approached the nest both parents actively participated in performing distraction displays, working together to lead me away from the nest.   In addition to the broken wing display they also engaged in false brooding.  As they scoot away from real nest they crouch on the ground and pretend to be sitting on a nest. I witnessed both maters engaging in this behavior as I walked toward them.  While many birds exhibit female-only care or male-only care researchers have found that biparental care is necessary in this species for successful raising of young. If one parent was lost, it was possible to hatch the nest but not to provide enough support afterward.

Precocial birds: Born ready to go

Killdeer hatchlings are remarkably well developed. They have feathers, they are able to see and they can walk within minutes of hatching, if necessary.  These features in offspring are called precocial.  After hatching, the parents don’t feed the babies. Hatchlings leave the nest within hours and quickly learn to forage for food themselves.  However, the parent’s job is not done. Both parents must continue to incubate the hatchlings which are unable to adequately thermoregulate themselves. They also provide protection by guiding them to safe places and warning them of oncoming danger.

The same killdeer nest in Canton Ohio but now with four hatchlings rather than four eggs. Photo: Joel Duff

It is difficult to see these hatchlings in their nest if you had a much lower profile while walking up to the nest. Here is the perspective of a cat or raccoon. Photo: Joel Duff

Parental care after hatching

The day after the hatchlings left the nest I revisited the location. From a distance I could see two adult killdeer on the railroad tracks, very close to where their nest had been.  When I came within 200 feet of them, they both started calling loudly and moved off at opposing right angles making themselves very visible. I knew the hatchlings must be on or near the railroad bed. However, it took me a full fifteen minutes of searching to finally find one hiding in plain sight among the rocks.  All the while, both parents were flying around me, calling loudly and performing distraction displays. One of their calls undoubtedly included a signal to the young hatchling to stay still. I was able to confirm this later after I had retreated for a while and waited until the parents gave the all clear signal.  Once the hatchling got up and started following one of the parents, I again moved toward them.  The parent flew off making the usual distraction sounds as the hatchling was running away from me. But I could clearly discern a distinct, long, single, high-pitched sound that was different than others I had heard before. Immediately, the young hatchling sat down and lay absolutely still.  It remained that way during the several minutes that I continued taking pictures. Not until I was far away for some time did the parents once again give the all clear signal and the hatchling popped up and went on its way.   

The hatchlings must develop during the summer to the point that they can take the long migration route to Central or South America at which time they will now be on their own. The parents will also make the trip and after overwintering a 1000 more more miles away.  The following spring they may return to the same location and make a nest in nearly the same spot!

There is one (at least that I know of) hatchling hiding among the rocks in this image. Photo: Joel Duff

This hatchling is obeying the signal given to it by its parents to sit very still. Here is sits among the rocks waiting for danger to pass. Photo: Joel Duff

Marvels of creation

The killdeer is certainly an amazing part of God’s good creation.  Had killdeer lived in the Levant region during the lifetime of Job, God could have told Job to consider His killdeer and how He has provisioned the killdeer with the wisdom to hide their eggs and their young in plain sight, to develop the young in the egg until they were able to see, walk and eat immediately upon hatching, and He ordained that both parents play a role from nesting until the point of their offspring gaining independence.  

It is easy to confirm that the creator God is responsible for forming the remarkable killdeer. He created the heavens and the earth.  But how did He do it? This is where agreement among Christians is hard to find. Consider your answers to the following questions: was the killdeer species, described above, created by God without any ancestral connections to other bird species?  If the original creation was a perfect paradise as some young-earth creationists believe, what was the function of their deception, camouflage eggs and precocial young if there was no predation or chance of dying? Were the killdeer preserved on Noah’s ark?  Is the behavior of the killdeer the result of Adam’s sin? 

We will tackle these difficult questions in the near future.  For now, consider the killdeer and marvel at a great work of our Creator.  


Additional photos below.

A killdeer hatchlings takes its first walk along the railroad tracks. Photo: Joel Duff

Another killdeer hatchling pretending to be a rock. Photo: Joel Duff

Two killdeer attend to a hatchling. Photo: Joel Duff

A killdeer sitting on its nest among the rocks can be difficult to see. Photo: Joel Duff

For my full set of photos please visit https://www.beechnutphotography.com/Killdeer-Natural-History/

Editing provided by MC

Comments

  1. Thanks for your article on the Kildeer, Joel. Another good post, and intriguing as usual.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Another question that could be added to your list is this: if the Flood story is taken literally, how did the killdeer survive when most of the earth would be covered in mud and silt, and eggs that would have blended in with rocks would stand out like sore thumbs? Also, if only 2 or even 7 killdeers were taken on the Ark (or whatever “kind” they belonged to), what are the chances those few birds would have survived in a foreign and hostile environment?

    Like

    • Glen, this is just where I will be going in parts II and maybe III if I get there. What I havent’ said yet is that Ham and friends believe that the killdeer is one of 350 shorebird species including gulls, puffins, and the Great Auk that are members of one Kind and thus all are derived from 2 or 7 total birds on the Ark. All of the behaviors of these birds were somehow all contained in just these few birds.

      Like

  3. Malcolm J says:

    Nice article, and what an intriguing little bird. There are a few species of lapwing in southern continents that display very similar behaviours, except that the adults will start to swoop on intruders if the other strategies don’t work. A masked lapwing in Australia dive-bombing you is not a pleasant experience! There is a species of lapwing in South America that shows almost identical behaviour to the Australian species and I have thought that the radiation of these birds would be difficult to explain from a YEC perspective. I’m looking forward to your Part II.

    Like

    • I agree. Not only would YECs have to explain both the behavior and camouflage aspects, but explain how Kildeers and all the species supposed to be of the same “kind” developed their special behaviors and morphologies (in both eggs and adults), all from 2 or 7 birds, and in a few centuries or less. I’m looking forward to Joel’s future installments that will deal with these issues. I’m also curious to see how ICR’s new “Discovery Center” museum in Dallas (promised to open this summer) will deal with these issues, and how much they will agree or conflict with AIG’s approach.

      Like

  4. Phil McCurdy says:

    Thanks for the lesson and the fantastic photos. I grew up in the Texas panhandle and chased killdeers flapping their wing as a kid, but never saw a hatchling. We have killdeer at my home now in central Texas, so they must have quite a range.

    Like

Comments or Questions?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: